Podcast: Play in new window | Download
A Quick Note to Listeners:
Before this week’s episode, Jen Schwanke and I take some time to answer a listener question. This week’s question is:
What do I do when my teachers are weaponizing a behavior tracking tool (nit-picking student behavior) instead of using how it was intended to improve behavior?
Listen in to hear our response!
Meet Justin Baeder and Keith Fickel:
Justin Baeder:
Justin Baeder, PhD, is Director of The Principal Center, where he helps school and district leaders build instructional leadership capacity. A former Seattle Public Schools principal, Justin is the creator of the Instructional Leadership Challenge and founder of the Instructional Leadership Association. He is the author of Now We’re Talking!, Mapping Professional Practice, and co-author of Cultivate and Activate. Justin also hosts the long-running Principal Center Radio podcast, featuring hundreds of conversations with education leaders and authors.
Keith Fickel:
Keith Fickel is a retired Texas educator whose career spans more than three decades as a teacher, band director, assistant principal, associate principal, and principal. He was named the 2022 Fort Bend ISD Secondary Principal of the Year and is widely recognized for building leadership systems that empower teachers while strengthening school culture. Keith brings the practical, day-to-day perspective of a veteran campus leader to the new book Cultivate and Activate: Building Teacher Capacity for Instructional Leadership.
Cultivate and Activate Through Teacher Leadership:
I love when a conversation about a book challenges me to think differently about leadership. That’s exactly what happened when I sat down with Justin Baeder and Keith Fickel to discuss their new book, Cultivate and Activate: Building Teacher Capacity for Instructional Leadership.
If you’ve listened to this podcast for long, you know I care deeply about helping principals grow. But one of the biggest reminders from this conversation is that schools become stronger when leadership isn’t concentrated in one office; it grows throughout the building.
Justin and Keith argue that teacher leadership is one of the most underutilized resources in education today. Rather than expecting principals to carry every decision, solve every problem, and lead every initiative, schools flourish when talented teachers are intentionally empowered to lead alongside them.
One of the ideas that really resonated with me was the framework they call the Four Gaps:
- The Authority Gap: Giving teachers real responsibility and decision-making authority instead of expecting them simply to implement decisions.
- The Information Gap: Recognizing that classroom teachers possess insights administrators simply don’t have because they’re closest to students every day.
- The Opportunity Gap: Creating meaningful pathways for teachers to grow professionally without requiring them to leave the classroom.
- The Culture Gap: Building a school culture where leadership is shared, recognized, and supported.
As I read the book, I kept thinking back to my own career. Some of the most influential leaders in my life weren’t principals. They were outstanding teachers who modeled excellence long before I ever stepped into administration. Those experiences shaped how I taught, how I led, and ultimately how I approached building leadership teams.
Keith shared one of my favorite stories from the interview. Early in his administrative career, he helped organize district professional development that was designed and led almost entirely by classroom teachers. The feedback was overwhelming: teachers said it was some of the best professional learning they’d ever experienced. Why? Because they were learning from colleagues who understood the daily realities of the classroom.
Justin reminded us that principals simply can’t, and shouldn’t, carry every leadership responsibility alone. Great systems allow schools to distribute leadership through clear expectations, shared decision-making, calendars, meeting structures, and accountability tools. Leadership becomes organizational rather than personal.
Perhaps my favorite part of the book was the chapter on the Opportunity Gap.
For years I’ve believed education often presents teachers with only two career choices: stay in the classroom forever or leave it to become an administrator. Justin and Keith challenge us to imagine something better.
- What if schools intentionally created leadership pathways for exceptional teachers?
- What if master teachers received release time to coach colleagues?
- What if schools developed specialized teacher-leader roles around curriculum, instructional coaching, technology integration, or professional learning?
- What if leadership growth didn’t require leaving students behind?
Those are the kinds of questions that can transform a school.
The conversation also offered an important reminder for principals, especially those new to leadership. Many of us begin by trying to shoulder every responsibility ourselves. We want to prove we can do the job. But eventually we discover that real leadership isn’t about holding tighter to authority. It’s about inviting others into meaningful ownership of the work.
Toward the end of our conversation, Justin made one observation that has stayed with me: Leadership work takes both time and resources.
If we truly value teacher leadership, we have to stop expecting it to happen “when people have time.” We have to intentionally create the time, provide the support, and whenever possible, compensate people for the additional responsibility they assume.
I closed our conversation by reflecting on something I’ve believed for years: caring for teachers and caring for students are never competing priorities.
The best way to serve students is to invest deeply in the people who teach them every day.
If you’re looking for a practical resource filled with templates, meeting structures, decision-making tools, calendars, and strategies for developing leadership capacity across your campus, I highly recommend Cultivate and Activate. Justin Baeder and Keith Fickel have created more than a leadership book. They’ve provided a blueprint for schools where leadership truly belongs to everyone.
Stay Connected:
To learn more about Justin’s work, visit the Principal Center, listen to the Principal Center Radio podcast, or reach out to him directly at justin.baeder@gmail.com.
You can connect with Keith Fickel by email at kafickel@gmail.com. Keith brings decades of practical campus leadership experience, and his passion for developing teacher leaders shines throughout this book.
To learn more about Cultivate and Activate: Building Teacher Capacity for Instructional Leadership or order a copy, visit:
https://www.solutiontree.com/cultivate-and-activate.html
As always, thanks for listening to Principal Matters. If this conversation encouraged you, please share the episode with another school leader. Together, we can continue building schools where leadership is cultivated, activated, and shared by everyone. Thank you for doing what matters!


